From Bitter Memories to Heritage-Making: Journal Article by Rommel A. Curaming

Rommel A. Curaming Philippine history / Memory studies Journal article

Summary

The article From Bitter Memories to Heritage-Making? The Jabidah Massacre and the Mindanao Garden of Peace by Rommel A. Curaming examines how the 1968 Jabidah Massacre, a pivotal and tragic event in Philippine history, has been memorialized through the Mindanao Garden of Peace. It explores how the site transforms painful memories into a form of heritage-making that seeks to promote healing and peace amid ongoing conflict in Mindanao. The study highlights the role of memory, identity, and heritage practices in addressing historical trauma and fostering social reconciliation.

Contexts & frameworks

The Jabidah Massacre is an event that holds deep significance in understanding the complex history of the Philippines, especially regarding the Moro community. Exploring this tragedy through various contexts helps to illuminate the broader implications it had on society and cultural identity.

Historical backdrop

The Jabidah Massacre occurred on March 18, 1968, amidst the secret military plan called Operation Merdeka, aimed at reclaiming the Sabah territory from Malaysia. Muslim recruits from the Tausug and Sama ethnic groups were trained for this mission but were not fully informed about fighting their Muslim brethren in Sabah. The massacre happened when some recruits protested their mistreatment and unmet promises, leading armed forces personnel to execute over 28 trainees on Corregidor Island, sparking outrage across the Philippine Muslim community.

The event profoundly affected the Moro people, highlighting their historical grievances against the Philippine government’s policies. The recruits, mainly Tausug and Sama Muslims from Mindanao, were promised payment and military roles but faced neglect and betrayal. After escaping death, survivor Jibin Arula’s testimony helped expose the massacre to the public, fueling resentment and heightening demands for Moro self-determination. The massacre is widely regarded as a catalyst for the rise of Muslim separatism in Mindanao, eventually leading to the formation of groups like the Moro National Liberation Front (MNLF). This struggle reflected broader issues of identity, marginalization, and resistance against state oppression in southern Philippines.

Cultural and heritage frameworks

The massacre has transcended a mere historical event to become a significant symbol in Bangsamoro collective memory and identity. It is remembered not only as a brutal tragedy but as a rallying point for justice and self-determination among Muslim Filipinos. The Mindanao Garden of Peace, referenced in Rommel A. Curaming’s article, is part of a heritage-making effort that transforms bitter memories into a space for recognition, remembrance, and healing. This framework approaches the Jabidah Massacre as a cornerstone for historical consciousness and cultural resilience in the Bangsamoro struggle, emphasizing the importance of memory in healing and political empowerment.

Themes and questions

In the article "From Bitter Memories to Heritage-Making? The Jabidah Massacre and the Mindanao Garden of Peace," Rommel A. Curaming explores significant themes surrounding the Jabidah Massacre and its lasting impact. This discussion raises important questions about how memories of such tragic events can shape identity and contribute to peace-building efforts.

Core theses

The Jabidah Massacre of 1968 has been a pivotal event in the Philippines, contributing to ongoing conflicts.
The Mindanao Garden of Peace serves as a memorial to the victims.
The massacre is often linked to the broader context of Moro separatism.
Heritage-making can transform bitter memories into symbols of peace.

Recurring motifs

The article highlights the Jabidah Massacre as a recurring motif in discussions of Moro identity and separatism. Symbols like the Mindanao Garden of Peace represent efforts to transform traumatic events into heritage sites. The massacre also symbolizes unresolved national questions, posing interpretive challenges on how historical events shape contemporary conflicts.

Study questions

How did the Jabidah Massacre influence contemporary conflicts in Mindanao?
What role does the Mindanao Garden of Peace play in heritage-making?
How does this event reflect broader themes of ethnicity and separatism?
Can public memorials like gardens alter perceptions of historical traumas?

Interpretation, close reading & resources

In his article, Rommel A. Curaming explores the complex relationship between memory and heritage in the context of the Jabidah Massacre and the Mindanao Garden of Peace. By examining how these memories are negotiated, the article raises important questions about the role of state narratives and the impact of collective memory on identity and reconciliation.

Critical approaches & debates

Rommel A. Curaming’s article on the Jabidah Massacre and Mindanao Garden of Peace employs a postcolonial and memory-studies lens to examine how state and society negotiate violent historical memories. The article engages debates on politically charged memory-making, nationalism, and heritage construction, highlighting tensions between official narratives and grassroots remembrance. Some scholars argue the state co-opts traumatic memories to promote reconciliation, while others see heritage projects as spaces of contested identity and resistance. Curaming’s work intersects with broader discussions on state power and knowledge in Southeast Asia, illustrating disagreements about whether such commemorations serve to heal or obscure historical injustices.

Key passages

A crucial passage analyzes the Garden of Peace’s symbolic layout as a site transforming "bitter memories" of the Jabidah Massacre into a shared heritage. Curaming uses metaphor and collective memory theory to show how spatial design embodies reconciliation efforts, while simultaneously revealing unresolved political grievances. This passage is important for understanding how public memory is negotiated through material culture and state narratives.

Bibliography

Curaming, Rommel A. "From Bitter Memories to Heritage-Making? The Jabidah Massacre and the Mindanao Garden of Peace," SOJOURN: Journal of Social Issues in Southeast Asia, latest edition. Includes related primary sources on the Jabidah Massacre and works on memory politics in Mindanao. Foundational studies: Curaming’s "Mediating and Consuming Memories of Violence" (2012) and recent scholarship on Southeast Asian historiography and cultural memory.