Analyzing "Araby": Journal Article by Rick Barney et al.

Rick Barney et al. Modernist literature / Narrative theory Journal article

Summary

The article "Analyzing 'Araby' as Story and Discourse: A Summary of the MURGE Project" by Rick Barney et al. offers a detailed descriptive analysis of James Joyce's "Araby," breaking down the narrative into 27 significant plot events and examining features such as narrative point-of-view, character traits, and temporal sequences without imposing interpretation. It emphasizes a methodical approach that distinguishes story components from discourse, ultimately challenging previous quest-based interpretations found in other critiques. The work highlights the pedagogical potential of "Araby" and contributes to broader debates on narrative structure, serving as a key resource for understanding story and discourse dynamics in literary studies.

Contexts & frameworks

In examining "Araby," it is essential to consider the various contexts and frameworks that shape the narrative. By understanding the historical, social, and literary settings, readers can gain deeper insights into the themes and characters that Joyce presents.

Historical Setting

James Joyce's "Araby" is set in early 20th-century Dublin, a city under British rule. This period was marked by a strong nationalist movement seeking Irish independence. The story reflects the cultural and political uncertainty of the time, with influences from the Irish cultural revival that followed Charles Stewart Parnell's legacy.

"Araby" explores the lives of Dublin's middle class and their struggles with identity and religious influence. Roman Catholicism played a significant role in shaping Irish culture, with many children attending schools run by Jesuit priests and convent schools. The story touches on themes of youthful infatuation and disillusionment, set against the backdrop of a society grappling with poverty, large families, and strict religious norms.

Literary Traditions

"Araby" is part of Joyce's collection Dubliners, which contributed to the early 20th-century Irish literary revival. The story combines elements of medieval romance and religious symbolism, reflecting Joyce's innovative approach to storytelling. Its themes of love, disillusionment, and the search for identity influenced later writers, such as John Updike.

Themes and questions

In "Araby," themes of innocence and disillusionment weave through the protagonist's journey. The story raises important questions about desire, reality, and the bittersweet nature of growing up.

Key themes

The story explores the loss of innocence and the harsh coming-of-age transition.
Frustrated desire and disillusionment are central to the protagonist’s experience.
The narrative contrasts idealized romance with mundane reality.
The theme of vanity and self-deception underlies the boy’s realization.
Epiphany as painful insight marks the protagonist's final awareness.
The story highlights the tension between imagination and fact in human experience.

Symbols & ambiguities

Recurring symbols include the bazaar (Araby), representing the boy’s romanticized dreams that eventually reveal commercial banality and disappointment. The street and darkened surroundings symbolize the dreariness and confinement of Dublin life contrasted with the boy’s idealism. The light and darkness imagery mark the shift from innocence to knowledge. Ambiguity arises as the narrator’s retrospective voice blends youthful passion with ironic adult detachment, complicating the story’s meaning about naïveté and maturity. The tension between story (events) and discourse (narrative method) is central to the MURGE project's detailed description.

Study questions

How does the story depict the transition from childhood innocence to adult disillusionment?
In what ways does the bazaar symbolize broader themes of the story?
How does the narrator’s dual voice affect your understanding of the story?
What role does vanity play in the protagonist’s self-awareness?
How do the setting and mood contribute to the story’s central message?
Why is the epiphany at the story’s end considered both painful and revealing?
How does Joyce use narrative structure to separate story from discourse?
What does the story suggest about the possibility of fulfillment in everyday life?

Interpretation, close reading & resources

The MURGE Project provides a detailed examination of “Araby” through a close reading that highlights the story's narrative structure and key elements. This analysis opens the door to various critical approaches and debates surrounding the interpretation of the text and its themes.

Critical approaches & debates

The MURGE Project’s summary of “Araby” takes a formalist and structuralist approach by dissecting the narrative into 27 plot-significant events and isolating narrative elements like point of view and character traits, focusing on describing rather than interpreting the text. This contrasts with thematic readings emphasizing youth, disillusionment, and the conflict between idealism and reality. Some debate arises around interpretations of the story as a “quest”: MURGE counters Freimarcks and Mandels’ quest theory with their close narrative analysis. Feminist and postcolonial critiques are less prominent, with scholarship largely centered on narrative form, epiphany motifs, and the story’s socio-cultural symbolism of Dublin life.

Key passages

The final scene at the bazaar is pivotal: the boy’s arrival coincides with its closing darkness, reflecting his internal epiphany of disillusionment. Joyce uses imagery and metaphor as the boy realizes his fantasies about romance and exoticism are vanity, marking a loss of innocence and the harsh entry into adulthood. The detailed narrative turn from hopeful anticipation to bleak realization showcases the story’s core tension between imagination and reality.

Bibliography

Barney, Rick et al. “Analyzing ‘Araby’ as Story and Discourse: A Summary of the MURGE Project,” James Joyce Quarterly, Vol. 18, No. 3, 1981, pp. 237-254. Primary text: Joyce, James. Dubliners, 1914. Foundational studies include Booth’s theories of narrative and Barthes’ S/Z. Recent analyses focus on epiphany and youth disillusionment within Joyce’s Dublin context.